SailNet Community banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
One of None
Joined
·
8,040 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'd like to ask some intelligent questions when I visit a sail maker next week.
this is the situation. My main blew out finally. I was sold a new in the box main from a C28 and it fits the boom perfectly, has 4 full battens 10ft, 8ft, 6ft and 3 ft. The sail is nice! the only thing is, it's shorter then the original. I'd like to have it modified to the height of the old sail. I've already been told it would be very expensive. I wonder. I do like the sail and at the price I'm getting it for I could spend another 3-400 bucks and still come out cheaper then a custom made new main. So could some of sail experts chime in here?
thanks in advance!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,146 Posts
I'd like to ask some intelligent questions when I visit a sail maker next week.
this is the situation. My main blew out finally. I was sold a new in the box main from a C28 and it fits the boom perfectly, has 4 full battens 10ft, 8ft, 6ft and 3 ft. The sail is nice! the only thing is, it's shorter then the original. I'd like to have it modified to the height of the old sail. I've already been told it would be very expensive. I wonder. I do like the sail and at the price I'm getting it for I could spend another 3-400 bucks and still come out cheaper then a custom made new main. So could some of sail experts chime in here?
thanks in advance!
Not really enough info. C28 comes in tall and standard rigs... The shorter and being obviously not the other - I suggest buy a sail that works... nothing any a sail maker can do will do you well financially all things considered.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
19,488 Posts
How much shorter? If it's only a foot or less, I'd probably live with it for a while and see if it really is a problem. If it's more than that then you're likely to lose significant performance, and besides it will "look" odd.

I'd bet it will take most or all of your "3-400 bucks" to modify the sail to fit - I'd think the best way would be to add to the foot, which is a busy work-intensive part of the sail. Adding panels in the middle will certainly require moving/modifying the batten pockets, again, a fairly work intensive ($$$) job.

Ultimately, modifications are probably not the best option
 

·
Telstar 28
Joined
·
993 Posts
Denise—

How much shorter is it?? I agree with Faster, if it isn't more than a foot... I wouldn't bother getting it modified without trying it first.
 

·
One of None
Joined
·
8,040 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Oh.. well it's about 2ft short .. It's on my boat and performs quite well too! And no, I don't have the $ for new main to fit my boat as designed.
 

·
midlife crisis member
Joined
·
975 Posts
Go to the sailmaker and ask, but my prediction is it will cost 75% of the price of a new main. I know very little about sails (I am getting a little experience with sailmakers tho), but knowing geometry, they will need to add the 2 feet to the foot, and then modify the leech all the way down, which means modifying the batten pockets. And then there is the sail shape...

How much roach is there? If a lot, and there is a little room on the boom, then maybe the leach can stay as is.

Let us know what the sail maker says.

Eric
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
515 Posts
Two foot short isn't a major issue sail it and enjoy.
What I would do is each time I sail, throw a few bucks into the sail replacement fund.
After a while you'll have the money for a new sail. Then sell that one and start the jib replacement fund.....

I do that with motorcycles, started out with one that was almost perfect for me, put some money away each time I rode, then bought a bike that was a closer match. I just forgot about the 'sell the old' part so I now have four bikes and three boats....

Ken.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,090 Posts
Two feet short in the “P” dimension is a little short. On your boat it will be like sailing with a permanent reef. I don’t think you would be happy with the performance on most days. Get a quote on the cost to convert into a proper sized main before you buy it. I’m suspecting that in the end it will about the same as a new main. To convert the sail will be problematic. The sail maker will have to remove the lower panel and replace it with two. He will have to add new reef points (you already have a 2<SUP>nd</SUP> reef). And re-taper the leach, modifying battens and their pockets. And in the end, you will not have the proper camber and shape in the sail. I fear that it just won’t set as well as your old one. Try quoting around with the web based lofts. They will sell you a ‘stock” sail that will fit your “P” and “E” dimensions. Try companies like Sail Warehouse in Monterrey Ca., Airforce Sails. North even has an on-line, low cost subsidiary. You will get a reasonable sail at a reasonable cost. You won’t get exotic materials, tailoring to your rig or an afternoon or two sailing with your sail maker. Check it out before you try to have something re-cut and sewn so it will fit your boat. Remember, sails can last a long time, do you want to be happy or sad for the long term?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
515 Posts
Not sure, but I think you're overestimating the performance hit.

Won't lose more than 10sq ft, (using the 2ft short figure) if it works, use it. (evidenced by her "It's on my boat and performs quite well too!" statement above)

the only time a short sail is a problem is if you're racing, otherwise, if you want to go out and enjoy an afternoon sail, it's no problem at all.

Ken.
 

·
Super Fuzzy Moderator
Joined
·
17,137 Posts
On our previous I tore the main right along the foot up to about 18" from the boom. Could not afford new sail so sailmaker chopped out the bad bit and I sailed like that for quite some few years.

Funny thing was that because the cut sail was a better shape than the old she actually sailed better than before.

OTOH...two feet is getting pretty close to being too much IMHO..
 

·
One of None
Joined
·
8,040 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
I've been sailing a couple of times now with the full batten main. It's quite nice handling and I'd say the roach more then makes up for the lost height. I'm keeping it. I'm sure I could sell it for more then I bought it for. Someday I will get enough $ together for well designed sails. for now I'm happy. appreciate all the input!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,309 Posts
At the end of the day, the only thing that counts, is "the ear to ear arc" if it is up, kewl, if down, trouble!

You may also be correct, in that if you have a lot of roach, it may make up for the approx 20# you are missing. when I had a new main put on last summer, the roach added 15-20# or so in comparison to my old one!

Marty
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,464 Posts
Hey,

I'm coming into this a little late, but here are my comments anyway. The O'day 30 is a masthead rig where most of the power comes from the headsail. If, like most people, your headsail is a big 150, I doubt you will notice the smaller main. If you have a small headsail, a 135 or smaller, the smaller main may hurt.

I would not recommend modifying the sail. You will end up some cobbled together thing that won't work well, and no one will ever want.

Lastly, a smaller sail is better than no sail.

Good luck,
Barry
 

·
One of None
Joined
·
8,040 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
Barry! your right on too! My boat is a slug without the head sail deployed. But I can sail the boat better now with this new Full battend main then I could with old main. I think I only lost about 3 sqft of area off the top and I'm sure I gained more then that on the roach of the new because it's almost a foot more roachy, receey, :rolleyes: moose meece mice:laugher
 

·
Telstar 28
Joined
·
993 Posts
Don't worry about it then... :)
Barry! your right on too! My boat is a slug without the head sail deployed. But I can sail the boat better now with this new Full battend main then I could with old main. I think I only lost about 3 sqft of area off the top and I'm sure I gained more then that on the roach of the new because it's almost a foot more roachy, receey, :rolleyes: moose meece mice:laugher
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top