[KeltiC]

I'm Kelly...and I'm new to sailing...TOTALLY NEW!
My boyfriend of almost 2 years recently bought a sailboat and has yet to put it in the water as he is waiting for some work to be completed on it.
We're looking forward to getting away on it even though we are now into the colder months!!
I'm sure I will have lots of questions for all of you who are experienced sailors!
In the meantime, I have just one question for now.
My guy mentioned that he would like a knife to use on his boat....for emergency purposes...like having to cut through rope.
I have been asking in a particular store for some info and havent had much time yet to google some info.
The knife I've been looking at is the Spyderco brand.
There are a couple that have been recommended to me and I want to make sure that I get the right kind for him (for Christmas...so I can't ask him!!)
So...which kind would be best?
There is one with a pointed tip and a curved, surrated blade.
And another with a straight edge...surrated blade with a rounded tip.

Some models that I've had mentioned to me by salespeople are the
-spyderhawk salt (C77YL)
-saver (I dont know the model number) used in a sawing motion I believe.
-atlantic salt (SC89SYL)

All of the above are Spyderco brands.

Which knife do you use?
And do you have any pointers or tips (pardon the pun)
when purchasing a knife for 'pleasure sailing'.
Is a surrated edge better than a razor edge?
Is it better to have a rounded tip...as opposed to a pointed tip?

Thanks for your advice!!

 

[n0w0rries]

I did a bunch of research on knives before I bought mine. I wanted the Spyderco Atlantic Salt, but just didn't want to spend that much. I ended up getting a Smith & Wesson knife/marlinspike off Amazon for $10. It hangs on a hook by the main hatch, so anybody can grab it in an emergency and if it goes overboard I'm only out $10.

The flat tipped knives like the atlantic are designed for rescue. So you can cut a harness off somebody without cutting them. That's why I like them.

The curved tip knives are designed to cut lines, the curve assisting with one handed cutting.

I like the serrated edge for cutting things in a hurry.

 

[rikhall]

KeltiC

In my opinion, you have picked a super product. I wear one very similar to the Atlantic Salt Knife Serrated. Mine is black and if I were purchasing again, I would probably get the yellow or orange one (easier to find, especially when dropped overboard)

I just looking on line, and the Atlantic Salt Knife Yellow Serrated are about $65.00 plus shipping.

Me, I prefer the "sheep foot (non-pointed) and the serrated blade.

I think the serrated cuts line (rope) better and I like the non-stabbing affect of the sheep foot blade.

My two cents worth. I think it would make a super Xmas present!

Rik

 

[klem]

I would highly recommend a sheath knife rather than a folding knife. Part of making a knife useful is keeping it accessible at all time which generally means on a belt but I do like the companionway idea.

If the knife is for emergency only, serrated will do a better job of cutting than a straight edge. A blunt tip is good because you don't have to worry as much about stabbing things and the point almost never comes in handy.

When sailing I normally carry 2 knives, a sheath knife which I made by cutting down a $20 boning knife(dull point, straight edge) with a spike that I turned on a lathe and on the other side I have a leatherman wave which is handy in everyday stuff like needing to open deck fills. I realize that most people don't like making their own knives and sheaths so a sheath knife that you buy is probably best.

 

[LittleMissMagic]

Check out Myerchin knives. They are a true mariners knife. They are handmade and several models are available, both sheath knives and folding.
Here's a link to their website:
Unknown Domain
I am on my second one, alas the first was left on a pickup's bumper and lost. I also use a spyderco at work, while they are good knives, they just don't have the personality of the myerchin.

 

[LinekinBayCD]

I like the blue Swiss Army type knife West Marine and some other retailers sell. It's not expensive and very handy both on the boat and around the house when doing some chores. In addition to the serrated blade and marlin spike that most boat knives have, it also has a two flat blade scredrivers one phillips, an auger, can opener, bottle opener (very important). It's a great gift.

 

[MarkCK]

My first sailing knife was a Myerchin knife. It was a great knife but in a butterfingers moment I dropped it overboard. Now a carry a $20 knife from Davis instruments that if I lose it I wont be that big of a deal.

On the other hand Spyderco makes a great knife and if it is a gift you would get a lot of points by giving that one versus a cheap disposable one.

More specific to the questions you asked. I would go with the serrated edge and a pointed tip. Although pointed tip isnt as functional on a boat.

 

[erps]

I like spyderco knives. They are so darned expensive that I'm pretty particular what I'll cut with mine. I carry one all the time at work and quite a bit of the time off the job too.

Another knife is a Vickie. These knives are not something I would buy for a gift, but they are something I would have on the boat. Commercial fishermen have these things lying all over their boats and they are very sharp. We always have a few on the work boat. They cut lines like butter. When they get dull, pitch it and get another one.

KNIFE UTILITY RED HDL 8105R - Seattle Marine

 

[Hudsonian]

I have used and enjoyed spyderco rescue knive with sheepfoot serrated blade(design similar to the Atlantic Salt) for years. The hole in the blade allows easy one handed operation. It's lightweight and not too thick. The clip allows me to secure inside my waist band just aft of my right hip. I forget that it's there until I need it and then it's readily accessible.

 

[scottyt]

i have a cheap west marine folder. its on a lanyard on my vest, i wont lose it. it is very sharp and not serrated, as i dont like serrated. i feel a very sharp straight edge does a better job at cutting rope, i think differently than most. i think serrated grabs on tough to cut rope, whereas a straight blade does not.

just keep what ever knife you get very sharp, dont use it to cut dinner. you dont want it dull at the worse possible time

 

[davidpm]

Kelly; this is may not the knife for a two year boyfriend but once you find out what kind of diamond he is talking about this knife is the knife equilivent of a D - Flawless diamond.
Mr. Boye only makes a few a year so once things get serious get your order in well in advance.

Boye Knives

 

[jmolan]

Search Results - LFS Marine Outdoor

This is what the deckhands fishing Bering Sea use. We buy them by the case. They also make a great $5 sheath. I have a few of these in a sheath strapped to different areas on my sailboat. You can strap one to your bibs or life vest real easy. They are rugged, will cut like butter, and light and cheap.
The serration is much less that a spyderco. Try to cut a small piece of line with serrations that are bigger then the rope.....no good.

Cutting Dynex Dux we were wearing out steel knives. These are the only thing we found to hold up to synthetic lines. Below is a great guy, single man shop.

$29.95 Ceramic Knife

Also another specialist. Killer good blade and material. Anotrher solo maker.

Boye Knives

 

[sailortjk1]

My guy mentioned that he would like a knife to use on his boat....for emergency purposes...like having to cut through rope.

Like most sailors, I too carry many knives and I have a small collection.
But in response to the above, and for my emergency knife, I have this with the blunt tip attached to the pedestal.....
UK Blue Tang Knife Hydralloy reviews and discounts, UK Lights

 

[jmolan]

David you beat me to the Boye....it is good! You can get the folder without serrations.

 

[davidpm]

Another knife is a Vickie. These knives are not something I would buy for a gift, but they are something I would have on the boat. Commercial fishermen have these things lying all over their boats and they are very sharp. We always have a few on the work boat. They cut lines like butter. When they get dull, pitch it and get another one.

KNIFE UTILITY RED HDL 8105R - Seattle Marine

Would you expound on these work knives.
I did not find "Vickie" Your link goes to a different brand.
What is the difference?

 

[davidpm]

Search Results - LFS Marine Outdoor

This is what the deckhands fishing Bering Sea use. We buy them by the case. They also make a great $5 sheath. I have a few of these in a sheath strapped to different areas on my sailboat. You can strap one to your bibs or life vest real easy. They are rugged, will cut like butter, and light and cheap.

Which one. There is a whole page of knives at your link.

 

[erps]

Which one. There is a whole page of knives at your link.

It's one of those $3.95 knives on the top row. Their real name is Victorinox, or Vickie for short. Same ones that jmolan linked to at LFS.

 

[bubb2]

My favorite sailing knife is a Myerchin. It is simple and Idiot proof and high Quality.

MYERCHIN, INC.

 

[KeltiC]

Wow...I never thought buying a knife could be so confusing.
I'm not finding many (or any) sites that include reviews, as I had hoped.
Nor am I finding any sites that tell me where I can purchase a particular knife in Canada...as I've decided I'd rather do without the hassle of online ordering and returns if necessary.
Therefore, from what I've checked out so far....I've narrowed my search down to:

A-the Spyderco Salt 1 C88YL
it has a serrated blade and a slightly rounded tip.

B- the Spyderco Atlantic Salt C89YL
has a serrated blade and a sheepfoot tip

C-the Tasman Salt C106YL
but it has quite a pointy tip.

I'm leaning towards "B"
And I'd put the links up...but the site won't let me.
It just copies and pastes:
:: Spyderco Search Results ::
for all three of them.

Anyways, thanks for all your suggestions and if you have any comments on the above 3 knives, I'd be happy to hear them and take them into consideration before I purchase a knife.

My next question will be in regards to Life Jackets and PFD's...but that can wait till another time, as I should be in bed by now!!!

Thanks again for your advice!

 

[Zanshin]

I'm a bit of a knife person - I used to sell (and train with) such manufacturers as CRKT, Benchmade, Spyderco, S&W, Böker, etc. and currently favor those made by CRKT (Columbia River Knife & Tool). Regardless of basic knife type, I would always recommend a partially serrated blade and above all - keep the knife sharp. There are many knife sharpening systems out there and I like to use the Lansky sharpener but as long as you get a quality system and apply it correctly they will all work well. My daily use boat knife is a large CRKT folder (see http://www.sv-zanshin.com/images/Big/FishTrapCutAway1.jpg after I had used it while diving under the boat to cut a melted fishing line); I abuse this knife and also keep the edge at a 17° angle (too fine an edge for a daily-use knife) but after every use I'll resharpen and oil it, wearing the edge down far too much due to the sharp angle but I can live with that.
When this boat knife finally goes overboard I think I will get a more sailing-specific knife but will most certainly stick with a half-serrated blade.