I never have had the plastic type tarps make it though the winter they always tear apart.
The yard this year has banned them from boats due to the damage they do to the boats once they start flapping all over.
So I thinking in spending some cash this year for a good canvas tarp. But just to keep the snow out of the cockpit so I can get onto the boat in early spring.
My boat doesn't leak
You are correct that many yards have banned them because they can and often do damage other boats in the process. A flapping grommet in 25 knots can do a number on a 15K Awlgrip job......
A well done home made tarp can be fine, but they are often not "well made"...
Fail:
Fail:
Fail:
Fail:
The key design criteria up here is PITCH, PITCH, PITCH. These covers MUST be able to SHED snow or they very often fail........
Personally I build my own framing and a buddy with the tools shows up helps me shrink it. I would get my own guns but he is so reasonable it would be too long of a pay back...
Our cover design has never held snow nor does any part of the cover or frame every touch our painted topsides.
Getting ready to frame her up:
Framing in progress:
My latest cross tie design can be removed for winter work and replaced from inside the cover.
Another design I came up with is to build into my winter cover a "vestibule"... No opening a cheesy zip door or fighting to get on-board I simply walk out the barn and up the ladder....

The barn also has its own shore power outlet on the second floor...
Sleek, slippery, easy winter access and does not touch the painted hull. Most importantly it never holds or retains any snow. The minute it gets to 1/4" to 1/2" it avalanches and comes off in sheets...